#73 | Posted: 5 Mar 2012 14:05 | Edited by: Tristra
the over all story makes sense, What I'm saying is the individual pieces have little foundation and need some polish to make them fit together completely.
Stop apologizing, since this is a draft it's going to need work, I bring up what I do because if it's not mentioned it may be over looked later and you may not learn from it and get better.
The trick of a good story is to get to a point where the reader doesn't see the grammar or text and just gets an impression of what is happening, and if your lucky follows a feeling you have laid out.
If there were anything I would say is "wrong" with this work it's that you write it very close to the suspense plotting of a cartoon, having cutaways when scenes are just about to reveal then returning later to fill that out at or near the end is something that came about due more to commercials than to good storytelling. Readers can be let in on many secrets, they should not always be kept in the dark. a single big reveal may be secret or a small hand full of secrets that give a surprise at the end, but even if the Hero doesn't know what is going on it's OK to let the reader know. What you want is the relationship that Bastian and Atreyu have In "the never ending story". (The first one not the sequels, they were just for making money not good story telling) Try to watch that if you can. When you get down to it Atreyu is Bastian's eyes and ears in the story, but Bastian sees things coming, he sees "the nothing", he knows where G'mork will attack from before the hero, and that knowing creates a suspense all its own. that's why when you get the cut aways back to Bastian reading the book you KNOW something big has happened that Atreyu may not understand.
The cutaways works for Cartoons because things are visually moving and relatively short, they are nonstop so it cycles back around to the scene soon enough and can keep you entertained all the way. But when reading, a scene break can often kill the mood and can be frustrating if over used. There is less visual in a written story, but that does not mean less interaction. In fact people will commonly make a deeper connection with a book than they will with a TV show because there imagination fills in the gaps and makes the world more real just for them. If they just get to the gaps and it cuts away to something completely different then you can leave the reader confused, you do it to often and you just wind up with frustrated them.
But even here you have a lot of leeway there is nothing "Wrong" with a scene shift, but before a cut away just ask yourself. "Does this HAVE to happen now?" "Is this a complete scene and not just a snapshot of something else?" and "Does it give vital information that the reader needs?" If it can wait in favor of things that need to be said then let it wait. If it's just some cut away of just a few lines, then try to work it into some other scene. your not setting the frames like in a TV show, your laying out the plot and mood for your characters in a both Broader and more specific sense, because you can cover there thoughts, there feelings, what specifically they see and how they feel about it. not just what is in the scene and what they are doing there. If it is not Vital to the plot, then try to squeeze it into another scene and not make it a scene on its own. Always remember, you will seldom EVER fit it all in, there are things you will become attached to that you just have to let go of in favor of making your story more understandable or flow better.
Watching a TV show is about like Voyeurism, your peeking in to the show through a window. Reading a book is interactive even if the reader makes no active choices, there imaginations make them a part of the experience, so it needs to be cohesive and it has to drive on feeling, as much if not more than look.
You have something good here, it's rough but it's good. You show a potential that many TG writers neglect, the desire to tell a real story and not just a self gratifying scene. It takes some careful work but keep at it. all my poking is just to keep you going. I will give advice but I will never tell you what your story should be.
I look forward to seeing more. |